What does a coffee bag cost? It sounds like the smallest line item in a business, but in this clip from Bricks and Risk Episode 147, Horn & Hardart CEO Dave Arena uses it to show how the math of scale works in real life. Today he pays about 70 cents per bag. When he first started and orders were small, he was ordering around 1,000 at a time, and each bag cost $2.07. Same bag, same company, a very different price, and the only thing that changed was volume.
Now put that next to the big players. Dave points out that large coffee brands can be paying something like 3 cents for a bag, or 5 cents at most. That means before a single bean is roasted, a small brand can be starting with a cost that is dozens of times higher than the competitor on the next shelf. And that’s just one item. In many businesses, buying power shows up across the whole supply chain. A bigger company isn’t necessarily better at what it does, but it buys at a level that makes every unit cheaper, and that gives it room to price lower, spend more on marketing, or absorb a bad month without blinking.
This is the hurdle Dave describes crossing as an owner of a growing consumer brand. You can have a product people love and a name that millions remember, and still have to work harder for every dollar of margin because the cost side of your business isn’t built yet. For Horn & Hardart, that reality shapes real decisions. Dave explained that selling through grocery and wholesale doesn’t make sense yet. A retailer typically expects a large share of the shelf price, and a distributor takes a cut on top of that. With a bag that sells for around $15, those cuts leave very little room unless the cost to produce is far lower than it is today. For now, selling directly to customers is how the business stays healthy.
It’s also a good lesson in patience. The number that hurts at 1,000 bags gets a lot friendlier at much larger volumes, but you only get there by surviving the early stage where everything costs more. Dave went from $2.07 to 70 cents, a drop of roughly two thirds, because the business grew. That progress is easy to miss when you’re in the middle of it, and it’s a reminder that cost per unit is not a fixed fact. It’s a moving target that improves as you earn the right to buy bigger.
There’s an honest takeaway here for anyone who has ever felt behind a bigger competitor. Being behind on cost does not mean you’re behind on value. Dave’s brand still sells, still grows, and still wins customers while paying far more per bag than the companies it’s up against. What it means is that the early years take more patience, tighter discipline, and a clear view of which battles you can win today and which ones you’re building toward.
If you work in real estate or insurance, the same principle shows up in your world. A solo agent often pays full price for marketing, software, photography, and leads, while a large brokerage can negotiate better rates because of its size. A small agency can face the same gap against a national carrier. Understanding where scale works for or against you helps you decide where to compete and where to partner. You may not be able to match a bigger player on cost, but you can compete on service, speed, trust, and local knowledge, which is exactly where small businesses win.
If you’re not in either industry, this clip is a great peek at why the same product can cost so differently depending on who sells it, and why that small brand you love may be working with margins that look nothing like the big names in the aisle. When you choose to buy from a small business, you’re often choosing to support a company that is paying more at every step than its giant competitors, and doing it anyway.
The lesson for any founder is to know your numbers. Dave can tell you the cost of a bag at each stage because he pays attention to details that many new owners ignore. That awareness is what lets you make smart choices about pricing, channels, and when to grow. Scale isn’t something you wait for. It’s something you plan for, one honest number at a time.
Dave Arena is the CEO of Horn & Hardart, and you can learn more about the brand and shop the coffee at hornandhardart.com or connect with him on LinkedIn under David Arena. If this clip taught you something about the real cost of doing business, send it to a friend with a business idea, and then go look at your own numbers with fresh eyes.

