Everyone Loved the Pitch, Nobody Wrote a Check #smallstartup
Bricks & Risk PodcastOctober 23, 202600:00:35

Everyone Loved the Pitch, Nobody Wrote a Check #smallstartup

Horn & Hardart CEO Dave Arena shares the startup fundraising lesson he learned when investors loved his Automat pitch but wouldn’t write a check.

He had the pitch deck. He had the projections. He had every number lined up and every answer ready, and Dave Arena, the CEO of @hornandhardart was sure he would land an investor. He was wrong. In this clip from Bricks and Risk Episode 147, Dave tells the story of trying to get the business off the ground with a plan to bring the Automat experience back to life, an idea he believed would be a sure thing for the future of the company. There was only one catch. The investors didn’t want to write a check for an Automat.

Dave is honest about what that moment felt like. Everyone he talked to loved the idea. But there was a gap between loving something and being willing to put money behind it, and Dave found himself standing right in the middle of it. He describes it as a disconnect between a great idea and the willingness of people to back it. It was a wake-up call, and not a comfortable one.

If you’ve ever put your heart into a plan and watched it stall, you know how this feels. You do the work. You build the case. You walk into the room believing the numbers speak for themselves, and then you leave without the answer you came for. For a founder, that kind of no can feel like the end of the road. Dave could have taken it that way. Instead, he took it as information.

He went back to the drawing board. Rather than push harder on the same plan, he asked what he could build that investors would actually support. The answer was to grow the business he already had, expanding e-commerce, launching cold brew, and proving that Horn & Hardart could be relevant, growing, and profitable today. A smaller round built on the current business, with a phased approach to the Automat later, gave the company a path forward that didn’t depend on a single big bet. It’s slower than the dream version, and Dave admits that the lost time is hard to look at. But it’s real progress, and the round is moving forward.

There’s a hard truth in that for every entrepreneur. An idea can be great and still not be fundable yet. Investors weigh risk, timing, and proof, not just passion. Dave also points out that he didn’t have a network full of angel investors or institutional money when he started, which made the process even harder. That’s a reminder that who you know, and who knows you, can matter as much as what you’re building.

It also says something about how to read a no. When the answer isn’t what you hoped for, it’s tempting to take it as a verdict on you or on your idea. Dave took it as a signal about the next step. Sometimes the feedback is that the idea is wrong. Sometimes it’s that the timing is early, the risk is too big, or the proof isn’t there yet. Learning which one you’re facing is the work, and the sooner you ask, the sooner you can build something people are ready to back.

If you work in real estate or insurance, this clip applies more than you might think. Every agent and producer has pitched something that didn’t land, a listing presentation that went nowhere, a client who loved the plan but never signed. Dave’s response is a model for what to do next. Don’t take the no personally, and don’t keep selling the same pitch louder. Ask what the market is actually willing to say yes to, adjust, and build proof until the answer changes.

If you’re not in either industry, you may be sitting on an idea of your own and wondering if it’s worth the risk. This story isn’t a warning to stop. It’s a reminder that the first version of your plan rarely survives contact with reality, and that the founders who make it are the ones who adjust. Dave didn’t give up on the Automat. He changed the route to get there.

That’s the real strength in his story. He didn’t pretend the setback didn’t happen. He shares it openly, along with the time it cost him, and he shows what comes next when you’re willing to listen to what the world is telling you. A closed door can be a redirect, and the path that follows can be better than the one you planned.

Dave Arena is the CEO of Horn & Hardart, and you can learn more about the brand and shop the coffee at hornandhardart.com or connect with him on LinkedIn under David Arena. If this clip hit home, send it to someone who’s facing their own wake-up call, and remind them that going back to the drawing board is not failing. It’s how you get to the next version.
Horn & Hardart, Horn Hardart, Hornandhardart, Horn and Hardart automat,