Would you Trade Income for Equity? #EmployeeEquity #smallbusiness
Bricks & Risk PodcastOctober 12, 202600:00:28

Would you Trade Income for Equity? #EmployeeEquity #smallbusiness

Dave Arena of Horn & Hardart gave his first employee equity in the company, Alcove Media, and she ended up being the buyer when it was time to sell.

Dave Arena could not pay Colleen what she was worth. He was running a real estate photography and media company on a shoestring, earning about thirty thousand dollars a year himself in those early years, and he needed someone to take over scheduling before the phone calls and texts buried him. Colleen, a friend who had been a real estate agent for about ten years, had offered to help with the admin work, and within a couple of months Dave asked her to do it full time on her own schedule. Then came the question of how to pay her, and he did something that most business owners are afraid to do. Instead of trying to match a big paycheck, he offered her ownership. She would help run Alcove Media, and in exchange she would earn shares of the company over time. That one decision turned a helpful hire into a partner, and it changed how the whole business worked.

In this clip from the Bricks and Risk podcast, Dave, who is now the CEO of the 135-year-old Philadelphia brand @hornandhardart , explains why the deal worked so well. Colleen was no longer just doing a job. She had skin in the game. When a team member owns a piece of what she is building, every late edit, every scheduling fire, and every slow week feels different, because the outcome belongs to her too. The hosts point out that a vested interest keeps someone engaged and wanting to grow the business over time, and Dave describes a company with low turnover, happy employees, and a great culture.

Then came the part nobody planned. When Dave decided it was time to move on and put Alcove Media up for sale, Colleen already owned twenty-five percent of the company. Halfway through the sales process, while Dave was talking to interested buyers, she told him she wanted to keep doing this for the rest of her life, but she did not want to work for someone else. She wanted to buy the business. After months of a process Dave found stressful, he sold his shares to her, and today she owns one hundred percent of a company that is still growing. The person he first brought in to handle his scheduling became the person who carried the company forward.

If you are a real estate agent, broker, insurance producer, or any kind of business owner trying to build a team, this is a lesson in how to keep great people. Cash is not the only way to pay someone, and a salary alone rarely makes a person feel like an owner. If you are an employee or a first hire at a small company, it is a reminder to ask what a fair deal looks like when the owner cannot afford the market rate, and what a stake in the business could mean for your future. Either way, the story hits on something real, whether you are signing the paychecks or hoping for a seat at the table: people work harder, stay longer, and care more about work they own.

There is also risk in a move like this. Giving away equity means giving away control and a share of the upside, and it takes trust on both sides. Dave had a strong relationship with Colleen before she ever joined, and she had been working in real estate for ten years herself. That trust is part of why the arrangement worked, and it is worth thinking about before you offer a piece of your company to anyone. But the payoff in this story is hard to ignore. A business that might have been sold to a stranger ended up in the hands of the person who knew it best, with the team and the culture Dave built still intact.

Dave Arena is a Philadelphia-area entrepreneur who started as a real estate agent, built Alcove Media into a company with a team of photographers and editors, and now leads the revival of Horn & Hardart, the brand that pioneered automated restaurants in Philadelphia and New York. His story is full of lessons for anyone who wants to start small, learn by doing, and build something that lasts, and this clip is one of the best.

So who in your business, or your career, is carrying more than their paycheck reflects? Watch this one all the way through, then think about what a real ownership stake could do for the people helping you build. If this clip made you rethink how you pay and keep your best people, subscribe, leave a comment with how you reward the people who build with you.

Follow Dave and Horn & Hardart here:
YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@hornandhardart
Instagram https://www.instagram.com/hornandhardartco
Facebook https://www.facebook.com/hornandhardart
Website https://hornandhardart.com
LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/company/hornandhardart
Horn & Hardart, Horn Hardart, Hornandhardart, Horn and Hardart automat,